"Hills Like White Elephants" is possibly the most confusing short story that I have read to date. Granted that I have read very few in my life span, I must say that this will always remain at the top of the list under the "Most Convoluted Short Story" category. Never before have I read a story with so many allusions, symbols, and implicit themes. I would have picked up on a lot of these elements if I had read a short background on the historical time period during which this story was written, but not doing so resulted in nothing more than utter confusion.
How was I suppose to know what 'to let the air in' or 'everyone does it' refer to? To an uninformed reader, it could mean a multitude of things! I remember thinking of travel and adventure when I was reading the story. The phrasing is a bit odd, but 'to let the air in' made me think of breathing fresh air at a national park. I thought 'everyone does it' meant that everyone goes on intrepid journeys. The context was perfect too - the couple had their bags packed, they were at a train station, and they were discussing their future. The implicit theme that Hemingway placed in the story is beautifully crafted and only a diligent reader would understand all of his allusions.
The lesson that I am going to take from this experience is that it is always good to re-read a story when it is understood the first time. It will allow for better comprehension skills and will advance my critical thinking ability as well. I hope that I do not have to learn this lesson the hard way again - through confusion and frustration.